Shopping Clubs as Part of e-Commerce Strategy
As a part of our regular breakfast meetings, which we use as study-hours for understanding the latest trends in e-Commerce, Martin Näwig and I cross-sected the business-model of Shopping-Clubs. Our aim was to understand the relevance of Shopping-Clubs to the e-Commerce industry in the current phase of market-evolution, and if they could make an impact on our own SME customers’ online-sales strategies. We examined some of the leading Shopping-Clubs, such GILT, Venté Privee, Brands4Friends and Zalando Lounge, their offers, their deal-newsletters, customer-bases and where possible profitability. The conclusion of our study was to derive a set of criteria the Shopping Club business-model could be leveraged to:
- Setup lucrative recurring revenue-channels
- Connect with customers
- Build customer loyality
.. for SME e-Commerce merchants.
The Encumbent Business Model
The drivers of the Shopping Clubs business-model are following:
- Product offers are visible only to registered users. Buyers can register for free, but there is a short ”selection” process, through which the potential-buyer is accepted into the Club
- Primarily, branded products are offered
- Enormous discounts-reductions are shown compared to advertised street-price
- Offers are time-limited, which means the discounts expire within a few days
- Primarily clearence/SALE/end-of-season products are offered
In effect, the promise to the potential-buyer is that by being a part of the (percieved) exclusive shopping-club, heavy discounts on branded products over street-price are possible.
Deal Marketing
Offers in Shopping Clubs are marketed primarily by email-newsletter. At least one mailing is sent out daily in order to announce one or more time-limited offers. To accompany the newsletters, elegant looking websites display highlighted sortiments of high-value branded products.
Value-Perception
The customer is enticed by the perception of exclusivity, lure of high-street brands, percieved savings due to heavy-discounting and the urgency of decision, lest the deal should expire.
The Problem
We feel the business model is solid, since it’s built on time-tested marketing principles of customer behavior. However we were suspicious of why the business-model is being driven by a few Top-10 players, and has not become a mass phenomena which every e-commerce merchant could offer next to his regular webshop. In effect, can the same customer-value not be offered by smaller individual merchants as well? We believe, yes, the same value-proposition can be offered by any e-Commerce merchant. However, the consumer has got cleverer over the last years, and doesn’t buy the lure of exclusivity, and takes for granted that if there is a massive reduction on this particular site, the real value of the product is infact the advertised reduced value, and it should be possible to obtain that price elsewhere as well. In addition, buyers are flooded with online-offers of just about everything, via newsletters, web-page ads (alá Adwords, banners etc) and even TV-spots for webshops. So a daily deal-newsletter doesn’t hold any special lure for buyers – it just gets mixed into all the other offers buyers are bombarded with. Most of all, what sticks out the most in the sites we have analyized is the lack of focus in the product selection, and in targeting a specific requirement buyers might have at any point in time. Without a connection to a know requirement of the consumer, (s)he is not moved to make a purchase. In addition, we missed one of the most essential drivers for e-Commerce today in the Shopping Clubs we analyzed – Social Media. Consumers want to talk and listen about products before they buy them. So the large Shopping Clubs could do well by integrating stronger and enabling conversations about their products on social-sites.
Success Formula for the Mass of e-Commerce Merchants
Focus is Essential
In order to get an audience for the Shopping Club business model, and build a profitable membership-base, it is essential for SME merchants to focus intensly on
- the product offering
- the target audience
A Shopping Club with general high-street branded collection of clothing and fashion accessories is not going to cut it! What would be needed, to remain with this example-segment of fashion, is a Jeans Club or a Shoe Club. The turn on for members of such a highly focused Shopping Club is that it offers for a single resort to a wide collection products, example a wide collection of jeans. Customer value such a site and the merchant behind it as resort for expertise. Combine with that Social Media tools, such as a comment-stream and customers get the value of recommendation from other buyers that have experienced the product-collection. Social Media tools also give such a Shopping Club the advantage of the merchant participating actively in conversations about his products. This in turn creates connection-points between merchants and potential-buyers.
Evergreen Products
Certain types of products are always needed by consumers. Jeans is a good example – most of us buy at least 1 pair every year, and always have a few in the wordrobe in few different colors and fit. Let’s just call such products Evergreen. Some other good examples of evergreen products are coffee-beans, wines, snack-food, flowers or office-supplies.
Merchants dealing with evergreen products can particularly effectively combine their wares with a Shopping Club experience, “socialize” it, and consequently build a loyal base of customers over time.
Margins for Discounting
It is also important for the merchant to ensure that he offers discounts only to the extent that his margins are not destroyed. With a focused group of buyers and a social-connection to them, the discount-pressure needn’t be exagerated, as is done by large Shopping Club brands like Gilt, Vente-Privee et-al. Buyers will still appreciate smaller, genuine discounts as the merchant maintains a transparent customer relationship as well as price-policy.
Extra Value Points
Focused Shopping Clubs, example a Wine Club, could combine their product offer with other value-adds for their focused target group, such as vineyard tours, wine-tastings or gourmet cooking classes on weekends. This attracts members of the Shopping Club to connect tighter with the “community” and extract more value from their participation. The wine-club Lot18 does a particularly good job at offering such extra-value.
Software and Tools for Shopping Clubs
euroblaze provides e-Commerce solutions to online merchants to design and launch Shopping Club campaigns. Our core e-Commerce shop-software, the OXID e-Shop system offers all the features necessary for merchants to launch and manage successful Shopping Club projects.
Contact euroblaze today for our Shopping Club advise and services!


euroblaze is a German e-Commerce company that specializes in delivering end-to-end
Web-Solutions for online merchants. We are experts and a Certified Solution Partner for the
cutting-edge, robust, modular and beautiful OXID e-Sales platform.
English
Deutsch 
